Skip to content
← All news
Industry

Seoul court raises KOGAS bill to $200m over KC-1 defects on SK Serenity and SK Spica

SK Shipping's award almost doubles on appeal over the Korean containment system that took two LNG carriers out of service

Elevated view of a shipbuilding port in Goseong, South Korea

South Korea's state gas utility KOGAS has been ordered to pay nearly $200m to SK Shipping and Samsung Heavy Industries over defects in the KC-1 cargo containment system, South Korea's own alternative to foreign designs, fitted to two LNG carriers that were then withdrawn from service for a prolonged period.

The Seoul High Court last week upheld findings that design defects in the domestically developed system left the ships unable to operate safely, and raised total compensation to KRW268.5bn. SK Shipping will receive KRW220.4bn, almost double the amount awarded by the lower court, and Samsung Heavy KRW48.1bn.

The case concerns the 2018-built SK Serenity and SK Spica, the first ships built with KC-1. The technology came out of a national research programme launched in 2004 to reduce Korea's dependence on foreign containment designs, above all those licensed by France's GTT. Both ships were withdrawn from service only five months after delivery when problems emerged with their insulation.

Investigators found cold spots where hull temperatures fell below permitted limits, creating a risk of brittle fracture in the steel structure. SK Shipping and Samsung Heavy sued KOGAS in 2019 for lost earnings, repairs and related costs.

The appeals court increased SK Shipping's damages after recognising further losses from the long withdrawal of the two ships, including financing, maintenance and the cost of replacement tonnage. It also rejected a separate claim by KOGAS that SK Shipping should pay damages for failing to provide substitute vessels.

The ruling remains subject to a possible further appeal.

This story is part of the Maritime Briefing of 17 November 2026.

Share

Never miss a move

Maritime, in motion. In your inbox.

The vessel sales, incidents, and market moves worth knowing, sent as they happen.

We email a confirmation link first, and you can unsubscribe anytime. No spam. Privacy policy